Protein Cheesecake Cups,
Three Ways
One no-bake protein cheesecake base with three finishes. Tiramisu 303 kcal, lemon strawberry 360 kcal, snickers caramel 385 kcal, all around 38g protein.
easyDietsync RecipesOne Base, Three Desserts
These three cups look like separate recipes and are really one recipe with three endings. The base is identical every time: 20g of protein Weetabix crushed into the bottom of a glass, and 150g of strained yogurt whipped with 30g of vanilla whey. Everything after that is decoration.
That is worth understanding before you make any of them, because it means once you can make one you can make all three, and you can invent a fourth without doing any maths.
The Numbers Side by Side
Tiramisu comes in at 303 calories with 37.9g of protein, 25.9g carbohydrate and just 5.6g fat. It is the leanest of the three because espresso and a dusting of cocoa cost almost nothing.
Lemon Strawberry is 360 calories with 38.6g of protein, 33.5g carbohydrate and 6.8g fat. The extra comes from the strawberry jam and the crumbled digestive.
Snickers Caramel is 385 calories with 40.4g of protein, 29.1g carbohydrate and 11.8g fat. The peanut butter is responsible for almost all of that fat gap.
Notice how little the protein moves: 37.9 to 40.4 across all three. That is because virtually all of it comes from the shared base, not the toppings. The calories swing by 82 between the lightest and the heaviest, but the protein barely shifts.
Why Strained Yogurt and Not Regular
Straining removes whey and water, roughly doubling the protein for the same weight and thickening the texture to something that holds a spoon upright. That thickness matters as much as the protein here, because a thin yogurt will sink into the Weetabix base and you lose the layered look entirely.
The 2% version is the right balance. Zero percent works but the cream is noticeably less rich, and full fat pushes the calories up without adding protein.
Why Weetabix Instead of Biscuits
A crushed biscuit base is the obvious choice and the wrong one here. Biscuits bring sugar and fat and turn to paste under a wet cream. Protein Weetabix stays granular, absorbs some of the moisture from the yogurt without collapsing, and adds protein rather than diluting it.
Crush it rather than powder it. You want texture at the bottom of the glass, which is the whole point of a base.
Mixing the Cream Without Lumps
This is where these go wrong. Tipping 30g of powder onto cold yogurt and stirring gently leaves dry pockets you find later. Add the powder in two halves and mix hard. The mixture will seize and stiffen alarmingly at first and then loosen into a smooth, glossy cream as you keep working it. That stiffening is the whey hydrating and it is exactly what you want.
The Three Finishes
For tiramisu, stir a 30g shot of espresso through the cream itself rather than pouring it over the base, then dust generously with cocoa. The coffee needs to be in the cream to taste of anything.
For lemon strawberry, warm 60g of strawberries with sugar-free syrup until they collapse into a loose jam, and let it cool before spooning it on or it will melt the cream. Lemon zest and a pinch of turmeric go into the cream, the turmeric purely for colour.
For snickers caramel, whisk 12g of peanut butter with the sugar-free syrup until it thickens and turns glossy. It behaves like caramel because peanut butter already has the fat and salt that caramel relies on. Swirl it through the top rather than layering it flat.
Five Minutes, No Oven
Tiramisu and snickers take about five minutes each. Lemon strawberry takes eight because the jam needs warming and cooling. None of them need baking, chilling beyond a few minutes, or any equipment beyond a spoon and a glass.
Looking to hit your daily targets easily? Track your macros with the DietSync app and explore our full high-protein recipe collection for more inspiration.
WHAT YOU NEED
Ingredients
- Straggato 2% strained yogurt (base)150 g
- Vanilla whey protein (base)30 g
- Weetabix Protein (base)20 g
Toppings
- Tiramisu: espresso30 g
- Tiramisu: cocoa powder3 g
- Lemon Strawberry: strawberries60 g
- Lemon Strawberry: sugar-free syrup10 g
- Lemon Strawberry: light digestive biscuit7 g
- Lemon Strawberry: lemon zest2 g
- Lemon Strawberry: turmeric½ tsp
- Snickers: peanut butter12 g
- Snickers: sugar-free caramel syrup10 ml
- Snickers: Biscoff biscuit3 g
METHOD
How to Build It
- 1
Crush the Base
Crush the 20g of protein Weetabix into the bottom of a glass or cup. Crush it, do not powder it - you want texture at the bottom, which is the whole point of a base.
- 2
Whip the Protein Cream
Mix the 150g strained yogurt with the 30g vanilla whey, adding the powder in two halves rather than all at once, and mixing hard. It will seize and stiffen first, then loosen into a smooth glossy cream. This base is shared by all three versions.
- 3
Tiramisu Finish
Stir the 30g espresso shot through the cream itself, not over the base. Spoon the cream over the Weetabix, level the top and dust generously with cocoa. Chill 5 minutes.
- 4
Lemon Strawberry Finish
Stir the lemon zest and a pinch of turmeric into the cream, the turmeric purely for colour. Warm the strawberries with the sugar-free syrup until they collapse into a loose jam and let it cool. Spoon the cream over the base, top with jam, crumble the digestive over.
- 5
Snickers Caramel Finish
Whisk the peanut butter with the sugar-free caramel syrup until thick and glossy. Spoon the plain cream over the base, then swirl the caramel through the top. Crumble the Biscoff biscuit to finish.
- 6
Serve
All three are best eaten within a few minutes of assembly, while the Weetabix base still has bite.
PERFORMANCE NOTES
Pro Tips
Powder in Two Halves All at once leaves dry pockets that never dissolve. Half, mix hard, then the rest. Push through the stiff phase rather than stopping at it.
Coffee Goes in the Cream Pouring espresso over the base makes a soggy bottom and a bland cream. Stirring it through the cream is the only way the tiramisu actually tastes of coffee.
Cool the Jam First Warm strawberry jam spooned onto protein cream will melt it on contact. Give it a few minutes off the heat before it goes anywhere near the glass.
ADAPTS TO YOUR GOAL
Modifications
Adjust this recipe to fit your goal
Target: Adjust macros for calorie deficit goals
- Use 0% fat strained yogurt to bring the total fat content to near zero.
- Swap peanut butter for PB powder mixed with water to save 60+ calories.
- Remove the biscuit crumbles to save approximately 40 calories per serving.
QUESTIONS
Frequently asked questions
Can you make a protein cheesecake without cream cheese?
Yes. Strained yogurt whipped with whey gives you a thick, tangy cream that behaves like a cheesecake filling at a fraction of the fat. Straining is what makes it work - regular yogurt is too thin and will sink into the base.
Why does my protein cream go lumpy?
Too much powder added at once, and mixing too gently. Add the whey in two halves and mix hard. The cream seizes and stiffens before it smooths out, which feels wrong but is exactly the whey hydrating.
Which of the three is the leanest?
Tiramisu, at 303 calories with 37.9g of protein and only 5.6g of fat. Espresso and cocoa add almost nothing. Snickers caramel is the heaviest at 385 calories, almost entirely because of the peanut butter.
Can I make these the night before?
Not really. The Weetabix base softens under the wet cream within about an hour and you lose the textural contrast that makes them work. Prepare the cream ahead if you like, but assemble just before eating.
NUTRITION PER SERVING
Macro Breakdown
37.9g
Protein
50%
25.9g
Carbs
34%
5.6g
Fat
16%
PARTNER OFFER
Fuel Your Gains With
FuelSync

Premium proteins to match your macros. DietSync readers get an exclusive discount.
Use code
DIETSYNC15
for 15% off your order
FITNESS STATS
Fits Your Goals If…
PROTEIN METRIC
Protein Efficiency
12.5g
protein per 100 kcal
ExcellentAbove average for a full meal. Ideal for muscle building.
STAY IN SYNC.
Latest recipes, challenge news, and exclusive offers — straight to your inbox.




