Healthy Protein
Magnum
Frozen banana and peanut butter protein bars dipped in a dark chocolate and peanut shell. 15.9g protein at 319 calories per bar.
IntermediateDietsync RecipesNot a Lighter Magnum. A Different One.
Worth being straight about this from the start. A classic Magnum runs around 250 calories with roughly 3g of protein. This comes in at 319 calories with 15.9g of protein. It is not the lower-calorie version, and anyone selling it that way is not counting properly.
What it is, is a bar with five times the protein and a composition that actually does something. If you want a frozen dessert that contributes to your day rather than just costing you, that trade is worth 70 calories.
Where the Calories Actually Sit
The shell, not the filling. One hundred grams of dark chocolate across four bars works out at 121 calories each, which is roughly 38% of the entire bar from the coating alone.
That is the honest lever if you want to bring it down. Switching to a sugar-free dark chocolate is the single change that moves the number meaningfully, and it changes nothing about the method. Thinning the filling or shrinking the bars just gives you a smaller dessert.
Why This Freezes Without Churning
Ice cream normally needs churning because plain water freezes into large crystals and you get a solid block. This mixture avoids that without a machine, for two reasons.
Banana brings pectin and a lot of dissolved sugar, both of which interfere with crystal formation. Peanut butter brings fat, which coats what crystals do form and keeps the texture soft rather than glassy. Between them you get something that stays scoopable-firm rather than freezing into a brick, with no equipment at all.
Thirty Grams of Almond Milk, Not More
This is the number to get right, and instinct will tell you to add more. Do not. Thirty grams is enough to loosen the mixture to something you can pour into a mould, and every gram beyond that is water going into the freezer.
Extra liquid is the enemy here. It dilutes the sugar and fat that are protecting the texture, and you end up with an icy bar instead of a creamy one. If the mixture feels stiff, work it harder with the fork before reaching for more milk. Whey thickens on contact and then loosens as it hydrates, so a mixture that seems too thick often is not.
The Dip Has to Be Fast
Freeze the bars completely, at least four hours and preferably overnight. A bar that is merely firm will soften in the warm chocolate and slide off the stick.
Melt the chocolate, stir the chopped peanuts through it, and dip each bar in one movement rather than rolling it around. The chocolate sets on contact with the frozen surface, which is exactly what you want, but it means a slow dip gives you a thick uneven patch where you started. Five minutes back in the freezer hardens the shell properly.
A Note on the Protein
The salted caramel whey is doing more than adding a number. It is carrying most of the flavour, since the base is otherwise just banana and peanut butter, and it thickens the mixture enough to hold shape in the mould. An unflavoured protein would leave you needing considerably more sweetener and would taste noticeably flatter against the chocolate.
To stay on track with your fitness goals, you can track your macros with the DietSync app or explore more high-protein recipes in our blog.
WHAT YOU NEED
Ingredients
- Banana150 g
- Peanut butter60 g
- Salted caramel whey protein50 g
- Unsweetened almond milk30 g
- Zero-calorie liquid sweetener15 g
Toppings
- Dark chocolate, melted100 g
- Peanuts, chopped20 g
METHOD
How to Build It
- 1
Mash the bananas thoroughly with a fork until completely smooth. Lumps will show up as icy pockets in the finished bar, so keep going past the point where it looks done.
- 2
Build the Base
Add the peanut butter, salted caramel whey and the almond milk. Mix well until creamy and just pourable. Add the liquid sweetener to taste. Resist adding more almond milk - work it harder with the fork first, as whey loosens as it hydrates.
- 3
Fill the Moulds
Pour into ice cream moulds and insert the sticks. Tap the moulds on the counter to settle the mixture and release trapped air.
- 4
Freeze Solid
Freeze at least 4 hours, preferably overnight. They must be completely solid before dipping - a merely firm bar will slide off the stick in warm chocolate.
- 5
Melt and Stud the Chocolate
Melt the dark chocolate in short microwave bursts or over a bain-marie, then stir the chopped peanuts through it.
- 6
Dip Fast
Unmould the bars and dip each one in a single movement rather than rolling it around. The chocolate sets on contact with the frozen surface, so a slow dip leaves a thick uneven patch.
- 7
Set and Serve
Return to the freezer for about 5 minutes to harden the shell fully, then serve.
PERFORMANCE NOTES
Pro Tips
Mash Past Done Any lump of banana that survives becomes an icy pocket in the frozen bar. Keep going with the fork after it looks smooth.
Resist the Extra Splash Thirty grams is the whole allowance. Whey stiffens on contact then loosens as it hydrates, so a mixture that looks too thick usually is not.
One Movement on the Dip Chocolate sets the instant it touches a frozen bar. Rolling it around builds a thick lopsided patch where you started.
ADAPTS TO YOUR GOAL
Modifications
Adjust this recipe to fit your goal
Target: Adjust macros for calorie deficit goals
- Use sugar-free dark chocolate to reduce calories by approximately 45 per bar.
- Apply a thinner chocolate coating using only 70g of chocolate instead of 100g.
- Replace standard peanut butter with powdered peanut butter (PB2) reconstituted with water.
QUESTIONS
Frequently asked questions
Is this healthier than a real Magnum?
It depends what you mean. A classic Magnum is around 250 calories with about 3g of protein; this is 319 calories with 15.9g. So it is not lower in calories - it is a bar with five times the protein and a better composition. Worth knowing which trade you are actually making.
Do I need an ice cream machine?
No. Banana brings pectin and dissolved sugars that interfere with ice crystal formation, and peanut butter brings fat that coats any crystals that do form. Between them the texture stays soft without churning.
Why did my bars come out icy?
Almost always too much liquid. The recipe uses only 30g of almond milk deliberately - extra liquid dilutes the sugar and fat that protect the texture. If the mixture feels stiff, mix harder before adding more, since whey loosens as it hydrates.
Can I make them lower in calories?
Switch to sugar-free dark chocolate. The shell is 121 calories per bar, roughly 38% of the total, so that is the only change that moves the number meaningfully. Shrinking the filling just gives you a smaller dessert.
NUTRITION PER SERVING
Macro Breakdown
15.9g
Protein
18%
28.1g
Carbs
32%
19.4g
Fat
50%
PARTNER OFFER
Fuel Your Gains With
FuelSync

Premium proteins to match your macros. DietSync readers get an exclusive discount.
Use code
DIETSYNC15
for 15% off your order
FITNESS STATS
Fits Your Goals If…
PROTEIN METRIC
Protein Efficiency
5g
protein per 100 kcal
ModerateAverage efficiency. Consider adding a protein source.
STAY IN SYNC.
Latest recipes, challenge news, and exclusive offers — straight to your inbox.

